Should You Have The Same Carpet Throughout Your House? (Answered!)

When decorating a home, it can be quite difficult to make big decisions that could cost you a ton of money. Perhaps, you’re looking at completing the flooring in your home right now and want to opt for carpet over other flooring options. This begs the question, should you have the same carpet throughout your house?

If you are trying to decorate your home in a manner that appears clean, spacious and uniform, you should have the same carpet throughout your house. It’s convenient and quite affordable without requiring special treatment when cleaning. 

However, it should be noted that having the same carpet throughout your house can end up looking a tad bit boring or predictable. 

Convenience doesn’t always amount to stylishness and this is something you should consider when deciding how to carpet a home. 

Pros of having the same carpet throughout your house

It’s affordable

What I’ve realized is that carpeting businesses are open to negotiating a better deal when you’re ordering a significant amount of carpet from them.

Being able to find a well-priced carpet that can be used throughout your home can be an affordable idea, especially if you take into account the fact that different carpets and rugs can significantly vary in price. 

You can even save a lot of money on the installation of carpets compared to tiling each room.

For these reasons, I would say that having the same carpet throughout your house can be affordable. 

It makes your home appear to be spacious

A great way to create the illusion of space is by creating consistency. 

In other words, using the same colors or items stretched across a surface will make it look more spacious than it actually is. 

This is one of the reasons why so many small and tiny houses are painted the same color.

The two largest surfaces in a home are the walls and floors which is why it’s so important to consider the color and type of flooring when decorating your home.

It can make or break a room’s decor which is why using the same carpet throughout your house is the safest bet. 

It creates uniformity 

Trust me when I tell you that it’s incredibly easy to decorate a house when there aren’t too many different elements to consider.

In my childhood home, one of the issues we had was a lack of consistency with flooring. 

All the bedrooms were not tiled and each of us had our own idea for what we wanted.

I had a carpet whereas my sibling had vinyl times. It was odd, especially since our rooms were all so closely connected.

This is one of those problems you will never have when you’re using the same carpet throughout your house.

Instead, the focus can be on the actual furniture and wall decorations to create some unique and beautiful decorations. 

It’s functional and safe

Another beautiful thing about using one form of flooring is that it makes cleaning up easier.

If you’re tiling, then you can opt for sweeping and mopping. If you’re carpeting, then all you have to do is vacuum regularly to keep it clean and fresh.

Unlike tiles, you don’t have to scrub it as often and it’s quite warm during the winter months. 

Another pro of carpets is that their soft nature can cushion a fall.

This means your kids are slightly safer if they trip and fall around the home as they run and play around, especially if you have thick but soft carpets. 

Related post: Does vacuuming damage carpet?

Cons of having the same carpet throughout your house

It can become boring

As much as uniformity creates the appearance of space and minimalistic decor can be easy to maintain, it’s not without flaws.

Having the same carpet throughout your floors indefinitely can be quite boring. 

You know exactly what to expect in each room and the problem is that the carpet will fade over years which will be visible. 

It limits your ability to decorate

When all your floors look the same, then the decor and wall colors throughout your house need to match that flooring.

The problem is that this can limit you over time.

Making home improvements or trying to change the color of your furniture or wall paint can end up being affected by the fact that you have a specific color carpet throughout your house. 

Then you also have to consider the fact that even your curtain colors have to be in line with that of your floors and walls. 

It will restrict you to some extent unless you opt for a plain white carpet throughout your home. The problem is that it will get dirty and discolored with ease. 

It can become unhealthy

Without regular care, carpets can accumulate a lot of dust, dirt, bugs and even mold which can actually prove to be quite hazardous for your health.

Personally, I feel like the worst danger is the development of mold. 

It has been linked to many health problems like respiratory issues and in this day and age, the last thing you want is to deal with a compromised respiratory system. 

Related post: How to repair water damage to carpets

It might not be suitable for high traffic areas

As much as carpets are soft to walk on, they’re not built for high traffic areas with a lot of foot flow. 

At the end of the day, materials in carpets are nowhere near as durable as tiles or wood. 

With this being said, you may need to prepare yourself for daily cleaning and eventual replacement due to wear and tear. 

It’s more prone to damage than tiles or wood

I’ve written about this before but carpets are seriously more volatile than other forms of flooring.

Why? 

Because carpets cannot withstand liquid and heat damage like tiles. 

In fact, water damage to carpets is something that can become costly if left unattended for more than a day. 

Let’s be honest with each other, when you have little kids at home, it’s inevitable for them to spill things on the floor. 

So, I’d keep this in mind before choosing to carpet your entire home. 

Alternative ideas for flooring

Laminate flooring

One of the most affordable and durable flooring at your disposal is laminated tiles. 

They’re really strong and don’t scratch as easily as one would expect given that it’s made from pressed wood but they are not suitable for all rooms.

The biggest problem is that they don’t necessarily look as elegant or high quality as other flooring options.

They just don’t look as good as the other options on here but they are still worth it if you’re on a tight budget and can find a design that actually looks really nice. 

Wooden flooring

From bamboo to oak, wooden flooring is a fantastic option for your home for several reasons. It looks absolutely rich and smart. It adds character to a room and it can be paired with a ton of decor styles. 

What I like about wooden flooring is how durable and scratch-resistant they are. 

And, if they get damaged, you can actually sand and refinish wooden flooring to look good again.

The main problem you will face in this case is the cost.

It can be very expensive to install wooden flooring throughout your home so keep that in mind when deciding what to do. 

Tiles

Other than wooden flooring, I don’t think anything comes close to topping good old-fashioned tiles. 

With the stunning styles and finishes available today, it’s hard to argue otherwise. They afford a great amount of versatility when decorating your home and are quite strong.

When it comes to cleaning, all you need to do is sweep and mop regularly.

It’s not going to accumulate dirt or very harmful substances because it’s so easy to clean.

That’s all it takes. 

The best part about tiling is that it can last a lifetime as long as you take good care of them. 

What isn’t so great is the tiling process.

Unless you have experience and people to help you, tiling takes a lot of work and is costly.

Conclusion

I really had a lot of fun sharing my thoughts and research on whether or not it’s you should use the same carpet throughout your house.

There are a lot of pros but not without some cons.

It really becomes a case of deciding what your budget is, whether you have little kids and if it’s something that would suit the rest of the decor in your home. 

With that being said, I hope you enjoyed this article. Be sure to share your questions or thoughts in the comment section below.